You were right! - Brexit and the EU: living, holidaying and moving to Garrucha - Garrucha forum - Costa de Almería forum in the Almeria province of Spain
Have Tools Will Travel
Grupo Platinum Estates
ASSSA Insurance
DELMURJ SL
Mini Digger Almera
UK DIRECT REMOVALS

Join the Garrucha forum

Join the Garrucha forumMy name's Alex and this is my website all about Garrucha in Spain. Register now for free to talk about Brexit and the EU: living, holidaying and moving to Garrucha and much more!

You were right! - Page 3

lindseymonty

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:27pm

lindseymonty

Original Poster

Posts: 30

19 helpful points

Location: Garrucha

Joined: 20 Jan 2023

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:27pm

Matthew wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:24pm:

Sorry Stuart, I cannot run with some of your beliefs although I'll always fight for your right to express them. Brexit was the worst disaster to hit the UK since Julius Caesar. Blaming the EU or its peoples for Brexit and its faults is folly - the faults are entirely within the borders of Britain...

.... 

I think Dario is correct and that the UK needs some kind of membership of the EU. Full membership is unlikely as the EU is in the driving seat for quite some time and likely to demand full use of the Euro rather than the GBP£ (on full membership). You know and I know that won't happen no matter what. 

Partial membership is the way forward for Britain. It'll cost, it'll be embarrassing for many, but it will work both ways.

I absolutely agree with everything you have said. Especially as I live in England and see it all first hand

Stuart47

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:44pm

Stuart47

Helpful member

Posts: 543

303 helpful points

Location: Sierra Cabrera

Joined: 30 Jul 2020

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:44pm

Matthew wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:24pm:

Sorry Stuart, I cannot run with some of your beliefs although I'll always fight for your right to express them. Brexit was the worst disaster to hit the UK since Julius Caesar. Blaming the EU or its peoples for Brexit and its faults is folly - the faults are entirely within the borders of Britain...

.... 

I think Dario is correct and that the UK needs some kind of membership of the EU. Full membership is unlikely as the EU is in the driving seat for quite some time and likely to demand full use of the Euro rather than the GBP£ (on full membership). You know and I know that won't happen no matter what. 

Partial membership is the way forward for Britain. It'll cost, it'll be embarrassing for many, but it will work both ways.

Matthew, I respect your servitude towards the EU, that is your wish. But it is not the wish of the people of the United Kingdom to be part of the EU. Since 1066 we have have been our own masters. 

I believe that change is coming and will be seen at the next general election towards the end of next year when neither Conservative nor Labour will hold a majority.

The youth have been grossly misrepresented by the mainstream media as not being politically bothered. They are and they are as sick as are most other responsible voters to how our country is being torn apart by these two reprehensible party's. At the moment the UK is a tinderbox waiting to explode. The people have had just about enough with our politicians lies and inadequacies.   

We will not be rejoining the EU in part or in full.

Stuart47

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:49pm

Stuart47

Helpful member

Posts: 543

303 helpful points

Location: Sierra Cabrera

Joined: 30 Jul 2020

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:49pm

John99andrew wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 1:51pm:

Try telling that to the folk who pland to retire in Spain and are now finding it difficult to move here now

It was never about people retiring in Spain. That was also our intention, so we changed our plans.

Are you saying selfishly that the wish of the people should be ignored because a few people want to retire in Spain?

Stuart47

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:51pm

Stuart47

Helpful member

Posts: 543

303 helpful points

Location: Sierra Cabrera

Joined: 30 Jul 2020

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:51pm

Steve2023 wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 2:48pm:

Brexit was a total mess. With many untruths along the way. But when they say we voted to leave , that is true. But it was by 51.89 % leave to 48.11% remain. A very small margin of 3.78%. So don’t put us all in the same bracket. We need more marches and protests. This is why the politicians won�...

...��t allow another referendum, now we all know the truth. And the economic disaster on the UK. If by some miracle Starmer who should win the next election had the  bottle to have another referendum if bet the results would be massively different, 

Nonsense and very selfish.

DarioMartin

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 8:14pm

DarioMartin

Legendary helpful member

Posts: 5418

6472 helpful points

Location: Vera

Joined: 16 Aug 2017

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2023 8:14pm

Stuart47 wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 6:44pm:

Matthew, I respect your servitude towards the EU, that is your wish. But it is not the wish of the people of the United Kingdom to be part of the EU. Since 1066 we have have been our own masters. 

I believe that change is coming and will be seen at the next general election towards the end of next year when neither Conservative nor Labour will hold a majority....

...

The youth have been grossly misrepresented by the mainstream media as not being politically bothered. They are and they are as sick as are most other responsible voters to how our country is being torn apart by these two reprehensible party's. At the moment the UK is a tinderbox waiting to explode. The people have had just about enough with our politicians lies and inadequacies.   

We will not be rejoining the EU in part or in full.

Right.  Neither Labour nor Conservative will gain a majority ... despite the fact Labour hold a 20% Lead and are looking to trounce Conservatives quite thoroughly.  The party you seem to think will guide Britain - Reform UK is it? are not even in contention and will not form any part of government.  Fact check 1.

Also, I take issue with your assertion that "nothing on the bus was lies" ..... except it was.  Because after rebates, UK was NOT paying GBP 350.000.000 a week to the EU.  Fact Check number 2 failed.

Fact check number 3 - you keep referring to the politicians in the EU as "unelected" - by that I can only presume you mean that you personally didn't have a say in who went to parliament, because a very swift look at the makeup of EU parliament will quickly show you that they ARE in fact elected by the perople of the country they represent.

Fact check 4 - Sovereignty.  This hoary old trope keeps raising its head I guess in the hopes that if you repeat the lie often enough, someone else will be taken in by it.  Britain never lost its sovereignty, all member states remain sovereign nations as quite nicely evidenced by for example Spain closing its borders during Covid against EU requests.  It is a Sovereign country, guided by the EU, but not dictated to by them.

I could go on pulling apart your rather weak and frankly foolish "Brexit Benefits" diatribe, but I shan't bother as I know you have done the digital equivalent of putting your fingers in your ears, closing your eyes and shouting LALALALALALALA loudly so as not to hear or see anything that might go against the fantasy world you have constructed for yourself.

There are none so blind as those that will not see

Advertisement - posts continue below

NaomiD

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 11:15am

Posts: 23

13 helpful points

Location: El Cabo de Gata

Joined: 1 Dec 2021

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 11:15am

Stuart47 wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 12:49pm:

Typical Champaign socialist Remainer comment. 

Do you object to the traditional French spelling of champagne because it’s too ‘European’? 😂

Andymac1951

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 11:46am

Andymac1951

Very helpful member

Posts: 1127

518 helpful points

Location: Velez-Rubio

Joined: 14 Oct 2018

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 11:46am

John99andrew wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 1:51pm:

Try telling that to the folk who pland to retire in Spain and are now finding it difficult to move here now

Can you please explain to me how it is difficult?  All that is required to move to Spain is that they meet the NLV requirements that is to say they need to show some euro 32,000 or is it 34,000 in the bank.  Now I would suggest that most Brits moving overseas, including Spain, are going to sell a property in the UK and with the prices of property in the UK as they are now, they would raise a princely sum, more than sufficient to place the required sum in the bank.  If how ever you are talking about those living off the state (pensioners) on the absurdly low UK Pension, with no property to sell, then yes they will find it difficult, if not impossible.  That being said they will, and are, finding it difficult to get by in the UK.  But of course at the other end of the spectrum you will have those who will be in a position to purchase a property valued in excess of euro 500,000 and will thus qualify for a 'golden visa'.   I will grant you that the 90 day rule has made it difficult for 'holiday home owners' (snow birds) who now can no longer spend the majority of their time in Spain whilst declaring themselves resident in the UK for tax purposes. Many UK Citizens are still relocating to Spain, and other parts of Europe without difficulty and I see no reason for this to stop, my opinion only of course, bur I think you will find the figures speak for themselves.  

DarioMartin

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 12:06pm

DarioMartin

Legendary helpful member

Posts: 5418

6472 helpful points

Location: Vera

Joined: 16 Aug 2017

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 12:06pm

Andymac1951 wrote on Wed Sep 20, 2023 11:46am:

Can you please explain to me how it is difficult?  All that is required to move to Spain is that they meet the NLV requirements that is to say they need to show some euro 32,000 or is it 34,000 in the bank.  Now I would suggest that most Brits moving overseas, including Spain, are going...

... to sell a property in the UK and with the prices of property in the UK as they are now, they would raise a princely sum, more than sufficient to place the required sum in the bank.  If how ever you are talking about those living off the state (pensioners) on the absurdly low UK Pension, with no property to sell, then yes they will find it difficult, if not impossible.  That being said they will, and are, finding it difficult to get by in the UK.  But of course at the other end of the spectrum you will have those who will be in a position to purchase a property valued in excess of euro 500,000 and will thus qualify for a 'golden visa'.   I will grant you that the 90 day rule has made it difficult for 'holiday home owners' (snow birds) who now can no longer spend the majority of their time in Spain whilst declaring themselves resident in the UK for tax purposes. Many UK Citizens are still relocating to Spain, and other parts of Europe without difficulty and I see no reason for this to stop, my opinion only of course, bur I think you will find the figures speak for themselves.  

Prior to Brexit, all that was required was to arrive, prove you had 12 months IPREM and a Padrón and you were able to not only live, but work as well.

Post Brexit, a hopeful migrant must not only prove 400% of IPREM available to primary applicant and 100% of IPREM to each subsequent applicant on a visa, but must also pay around £512 non refundable just for the visa application.  That just gets you the NLV, assuming all your paperwork is correct.  There are other costs attached with obtaining doctors certificates and the like, which all mount up to a hefty fee on top of the visa application itself. If you’re intending retiring here, it puts it out of reach now to many pensioners.

If you now want to come here ahead of retirement and actually work, then you have to go through the process of applying for a Work Permit.  Considering there are two basic ways to get one, and one of those is to have a skill on the shortage list AND then find a company in Spain to sponsor you with a contrato completo, that in reality narrows it down to self-employed … which requires at minimum a solid business plan to be presented as well as letters of intent from prospective clients to even get close to a work permit.  Not impossible - but certainly not easy.

There is of course the Digital Nomad visa, which again is a path to residency.  But even then there are restrictions on top of other requirements e.g. financial, in that only a very very small percentage of income can be derived from companies based in Spain. 

To say that it is not more difficult to now move to Spain is at best disingenuous and at worst willfully blind to the realities.

SonderB

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 12:13pm

SonderB

Helpful member

Posts: 102

99 helpful points

Location: Vera

Joined: 29 Nov 2021

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 12:13pm

Matthew wrote on Tue Sep 19, 2023 10:15am:

This is a serious subject still. Keir Starmer anticipating that he will be Prime Minister after the next general election in the UK appears to be just rattling a few opinions around. For me, he appears to want to get much at no or low cost. He's just short of placing an advertisement on this foru...

...m offering to feed your cat and walk your dog for three winter months provided you give him and his family accommodation free of charge.

Stuart is right about one thing though - the EU now has all the cards and the UK can only look on hoping that somebody will throw them an ace. The war in Ukraine seems to be deflecting public opinion in the UK from UK Reality. The EU is intent on expanding and interference from the UK to many (except us Irish) is on a par with political interference from Turkey. 

Why is Ireland the exception (of throwing smiling eyes towards the UK)? - Watch that space. The Good Friday Agreement (brought peace somehow to Northern Ireland and before had been championed by Mow Mowlam (my favourite UK politician) and Tony Blair. Brexit has weakened that Agreement and one day not too far away is the unthinkable. Keep an eye on interviews of Jeffrey Donaldson and even some of his supporters. Not only are they intent on offending (I'm being careful with semantics) the nationalist population of Northern Ireland, but everybody in the Republic of Ireland too. Mary McAleese (former President of RoI and resident of Northern Ireland) indicated the weakening of the GFA (Good Friday Agreement) only last weekend and like me blames Brexit. 

I jumped at the offer for £5.00 electronic membership of the Sunday Times and The Times for 12 months (excellent deal I covered in a previous thread). Especially the Sunday Times has been excellent value. But, I fear what is happening on a large scale in the UK , not just towards NI but generally towards the EU and even RoI. I spent 3 weeks touring in South Wales (spiritual home for Mrs Matt and me) and along the south coast of England. I don't know what newspapers they're reading (or if they are reading any) but a growing consensus points a blaming finger towards the EU which (to me) is a surprise. 

I'll return to the subjects of our visit to Wales, UK and blaming finger later should this thread develop. 

I can see no amount of common sense will change the Brexiters howling against the injustice of it all.

The EU has a lot of issues. Which is why it was very important to have the UK, at the EU table, to hold them in check.

Sovereign states live and die by trading with their neighbours. And by our neighbours, I don't mean selling motor cars to some sandy-rock jutting out of the sea, in the Pacific. As the UK Trade Minister Kemi Badnoch, seems to think is an excellent idea.

Our next door neighbours are all the sovereign countries that now make up the EU.

As a sovereign (outside the EU) country, the UK has to now negotiate with each of these sovereign EU countries, in order to export anything to them. And they require checks on each and every piece of stuff that is exported into their sovereign realm.

This is what sovereign countries do. Have control over their borders.

The UK at present does not not have control over its borders. And is not applying any checks on imports from the EU.

But of course, the UK as a sovereign country, has the right to allow untaxed rubbish to flow in without any import checks.

The UK has once again postponed import controls. Because this would increase inflation. Which has started to fall. 

(Under the Tory strategy, the government was expected to introduce a charge of up to £43 on each consignment of food or plant imports arriving in the UK, whether or not they need to be checked.)

It would take 50yrs, Jacob Rees-Mogg once said, before the UK would reap the benefits of Brexit. 

I believe his investment company reaped the benefits immediately after the Leave vote. When Sterling collapsed. 

On the subject of EU Passports, I would like to know, just how many British MPs hold EU passports.

Is it even allowed? 


lindseymonty

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 2:39pm

lindseymonty

Original Poster

Posts: 30

19 helpful points

Location: Garrucha

Joined: 20 Jan 2023

Posted: Wed Sep 20, 2023 2:39pm

DarioMartin wrote on Wed Sep 20, 2023 12:06pm:

Prior to Brexit, all that was required was to arrive, prove you had 12 months IPREM and a Padrón and you were able to not only live, but work as well.

Post Brexit, a hopeful migrant must not only prove 400% of IPREM available to primary applicant and 100% of IPREM to each subsequent applicant on a visa, but must also pay around £512 non refundable just for the visa application.  That just gets you the NLV, assuming all your paperwork is c...

...orrect.  There are other costs attached with obtaining doctors certificates and the like, which all mount up to a hefty fee on top of the visa application itself. If you’re intending retiring here, it puts it out of reach now to many pensioners.

If you now want to come here ahead of retirement and actually work, then you have to go through the process of applying for a Work Permit.  Considering there are two basic ways to get one, and one of those is to have a skill on the shortage list AND then find a company in Spain to sponsor you with a contrato completo, that in reality narrows it down to self-employed … which requires at minimum a solid business plan to be presented as well as letters of intent from prospective clients to even get close to a work permit.  Not impossible - but certainly not easy.

There is of course the Digital Nomad visa, which again is a path to residency.  But even then there are restrictions on top of other requirements e.g. financial, in that only a very very small percentage of income can be derived from companies based in Spain. 

To say that it is not more difficult to now move to Spain is at best disingenuous and at worst willfully blind to the realities.

In my case i wanted to rent out my house in England for a year ( very possible in my area) to experience the Spanish culture in a total immersion sense. I need to rent my house out to have enough money to rent a flat in your area and live well. But renting it out for 3 months is not possible. With a NLV you need to register at the local gov and pay income tax after 3 months which I wouldn’t be able to afford to do so a no go too.

Sign up for free or login to reply to this topic

Want to reply to this topic? Login or register for free to post your message:

Find more Brexit and the EU topics from a particular area:


Register for free!

Login to your account

Have Tools Will Travel
Grupo Platinum Estates
ASSSA Insurance
DELMURJ SL
Mini Digger Almera
UK DIRECT REMOVALS
Advertise your business here
Advertise your property
Help with my computer